Should You Open Carry: Pros, Cons, and Key Considerations

Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. Understanding the Basics of Open Carry
3. The Advantages of Open Carrying
4. The Disadvantages and Risks
5. Open Carry in the Backcountry vs. Urban Settings
6. Essential Gear for Open Carry
7. Practical Steps for Safely Carrying Openly
8. The Myth of "Deterrence"
9. Training and Proficiency
10. Maintaining Your Equipment
11. Conclusion
12. FAQ

Introduction

You’re at a trailhead, adjusting the straps on your pack and checking your hydration bladder. Your sidearm is currently tucked away, but as you prepare to head into territory known for predators or remote trails with limited cellular service, you face a common dilemma: should you open carry? At BattlBox, we believe that the right gear only works if you have the right mindset and strategy to go with it. Choosing how to carry a firearm is one of the most personal and consequential decisions an outdoor enthusiast or EDC (everyday carry) practitioner can make. This article covers the tactical advantages, social implications, and essential gear required for open carry. Ultimately, your choice should depend on a balance of legal compliance, environmental context, and your personal proficiency with your equipment. If you’re looking to build your kit with gear that’s been vetted by professionals, consider subscribing to BattlBox.

Quick Answer: Open carry involves wearing a firearm in plain view, typically in a belt holster. It offers faster access and greater comfort during physical activity like hiking, but it sacrifices the element of surprise and can draw unwanted attention in populated areas.

Understanding the Basics of Open Carry

Open carry refers to the practice of wearing a firearm in a manner that is clearly visible to the casual observer. This is most commonly done with a holster worn outside the waistband (OWB) on a sturdy belt. Unlike concealed carry, where the goal is to keep the weapon hidden under clothing, open carry makes the presence of the firearm a known factor in your environment. For a broader framework, The Survival 13 is worth reading.

The legality of this practice varies wildly across the United States. Some states are "permissive," meaning no permit is required to carry openly. Others are "licensed," requiring a state-issued permit, and some ban the practice entirely in most public spaces. Before you even strap on a holster, your first responsibility is to research the specific statutes in your state and any municipality you plan to visit. If you’re trying to understand how trail-ready gear changes the equation, Backpacking For Beginners: Your Ultimate Guide to Outdoor Adventure is a useful next read.

Beyond the legalities, open carry is often viewed through two different lenses: the backcountry and the urban environment. In the woods, an exposed sidearm is often seen as a practical tool for defense against wildlife. In a suburban shopping center, it is often viewed as a political or tactical statement. Understanding these contexts is the first step in deciding if it is the right move for you.

The Advantages of Open Carrying

One of the primary benefits of open carry is the ease and speed of the draw. When a firearm is concealed, you must first clear a cover garment—like a shirt, jacket, or vest—before you can even establish a grip on the weapon. In a high-stress situation where seconds count, removing that extra step can significantly decrease your draw time. If you want to pair that kind of carry with a broader outdoor setup, What Gear Do You Need for Backpacking? is worth a look.

Comfort is another major factor, especially during long days in the field. Concealed carry holsters, particularly inside-the-waistband (IWB) models, can press against the skin and become uncomfortable during strenuous activities like climbing or long-distance trekking. Open carry holsters sit outside the clothing, allowing for better weight distribution and airflow. For a setup built around that kind of practicality, our EDC collection is a natural fit.

• Accessibility with Gear: If you are wearing a heavy rucksack with a thick hip belt, a concealed firearm at the appendix or 4 o'clock position becomes nearly impossible to reach. An open-carry holster or a chest rig ensures your sidearm remains accessible even when you’re fully geared up, especially with a reinforced EDC belt.
• Larger Firearm Options: Concealment often forces you to carry sub-compact or "micro" pistols that are harder to shoot accurately. Open carry allows you to comfortably carry a full-sized duty pistol with a longer sight radius and higher magazine capacity.
• Mechanical Reliability: Because the holster is not pressed against your body or muffled by clothing, there is less chance of fabric snagging in the slide or interfering with your draw stroke.

Key Takeaway: Open carry is often the most practical choice for backcountry environments where physical comfort and rapid access to a full-sized firearm are prioritized over discretion.

The Disadvantages and Risks

The most significant tactical disadvantage of open carry is the loss of the element of surprise. If you are targeted by a criminal actor, the fact that you are armed is immediately apparent. This could make you the "first target" in a coordinated incident, as an attacker may seek to neutralize the armed individual before proceeding with their plan. That is why how to choose a concealed carry holster is such a useful starting point when you’re comparing carry styles.

Weapon retention is a critical concern when carrying openly. When your firearm is visible, it is accessible not just to you, but to anyone within arm's reach. This is why specialized gear is non-negotiable for open carry. Without a retention holster and proper situational awareness, you risk having your own weapon taken from you in a crowd or a close-quarters struggle.

• Social and Legal Friction: Even in states where open carry is legal, it can lead to "man with a gun" calls to local law enforcement. Dealing with nervous bystanders or being asked to leave private businesses can become a frequent occurrence.
• Situational Awareness Demands: You cannot "turn off" your awareness when open carrying. You must constantly monitor your surroundings to ensure no one is positioning themselves to grab your firearm.
• Environmental Exposure: An exposed firearm is more susceptible to the elements. Rain, mud, and dust can get into the holster and the action of the gun more easily than if it were tucked under a jacket.

Open Carry in the Backcountry vs. Urban Settings

In the wilderness, open carry is generally more accepted and practical. Most hikers and hunters recognize a sidearm as a "just in case" tool for aggressive bears, cougars, or two-legged threats in remote areas. On the trail, you are less likely to encounter people who are startled by the sight of a firearm, and the physical demands of hiking make the comfort of an OWB holster a major plus. If you’re loading out for the trail, a BattlBox 30L Dry Bag can help keep key gear sealed and organized.

In urban or suburban settings, the dynamic shifts significantly. Carrying openly in a grocery store or a city park often invites scrutiny. While it is your right in many places, you must weigh whether the tactical advantage of a faster draw outweighs the potential for social conflict or becoming a target of opportunity. Many experienced EDC practitioners choose to carry concealed in town, and the Covert Pistol Planner is one way to keep that option discreet.

Essential Gear for Open Carry

You cannot simply use any holster for open carry; you need a dedicated retention system. Holsters are categorized by "Levels" of retention. A Level 1 holster uses friction alone to hold the gun. This is generally insufficient for open carry in public. A Level 2 or Level 3 holster requires the user to deactivate one or more mechanical locks (like a thumb break or a hood) before the gun can be drawn. This prevents someone else from easily pulling the gun out of your holster.

A high-quality gun belt is the foundation of your carry system. A standard leather belt from a department store will sag and twist under the weight of a loaded full-size handgun. You need a reinforced belt—often made of stiff nylon or dual-layer leather—designed specifically to support the weight of a firearm and holster. This keeps the gun in a consistent position and makes the weight "disappear" on your hips. For belt-friendly carry accessories, our Clothing & Accessories collection is a solid place to browse.

We have featured various robust belts and holster attachments in our past missions, and we always emphasize that your belt is just as important as the holster itself. If your belt fails, your draw will be inconsistent, and your comfort will plummet.

Choosing the Right Holster Material

1. Kydex: A hard thermoplastic that is custom-molded to your specific firearm. It offers a "click" into place and excellent durability. It doesn't hold moisture, making it great for outdoor use. For a deeper dive into selection criteria, How to Choose a Concealed Carry Holster: A Comprehensive Guide is a useful companion read.
2. Leather: Offers a classic look and breaks in over time to become very comfortable. However, leather can soften too much over years of use, potentially interfering with the trigger guard. If comfort is your top priority, What is the Most Comfortable Concealed Carry Holster? is worth reading.
3. Hybrid: Combines a leather backing for comfort with a Kydex shell for retention. These are popular but can be bulky for OWB carry. If you want to compare carry gear beyond the holster itself, our EDC collection is a good browse.

Practical Steps for Safely Carrying Openly

Step 1: Check Local and State Laws. / Never assume that because you are in a "pro-gun" state, every area is open-carry friendly. Check for "gun-free zone" signs and local ordinances that might supersede state law.

Step 2: Invest in a Level 2 or Level 3 Retention Holster. / Ensure the holster is made specifically for your make and model of firearm. Practice deactivating the retention mechanisms until the movement is muscle memory.

Step 3: Choose a Reinforced Gun Belt. / The belt should be at least 1.5 inches wide and stiff enough to hold its shape when you've got a full loadout on it. This prevents the holster from flopping outward away from your body. A belt that sturdy is easier to find in our Clothing & Accessories collection.

Step 4: Practice Your Draw Stroke. / Using an unloaded firearm (triple-check that it is clear), practice drawing from your open-carry holster. Do this while wearing your typical outdoor gear, including a backpack, to ensure nothing interferes with the grip. If you want a visual refresher, our videos page is a useful next stop.

Step 5: Master Situational Awareness. / When carrying openly, you must adopt the "eyes up" mentality. Be aware of who is behind you and maintain a "reactionary gap" between yourself and strangers in crowded areas.

Note: If you are using a chest rig for hiking, ensure that the straps do not interfere with your backpack's quick-release buckles. In an emergency, you don't want your firearm tangled in your pack straps.

The Myth of "Deterrence"

Myth: "If a criminal sees my gun, they will be too scared to attack me." Fact: While some predators may be deterred, others may see your firearm as a challenge or an asset to be stolen. Never rely on the sight of a gun to keep you safe; rely on your training and awareness.

Deterrence is a psychological factor that is impossible to guarantee. While it is true that many opportunistic criminals look for easy targets, a visible firearm can also escalate a situation that might have otherwise remained verbal. Relying on the "scare factor" of a firearm is a dangerous strategy. You should carry with the assumption that the firearm is there for your use if a life-threatening situation arises, not as a badge of invincibility.

Training and Proficiency

Carrying a gun is a heavy responsibility that requires ongoing training. If you choose to open carry, you should seek out professional instruction that includes weapon retention drills. These drills teach you how to protect your firearm if someone tries to grab it. If you’re building out the rest of your kit, Best Multitools for Everyday Carry (EDC) is a good companion read.

You should also practice shooting from various positions. In the backcountry, you might not be standing perfectly upright on a flat range. You could be on a slope, kneeling, or trying to move away from an animal. Practice drawing and firing (where legal and safe) in environments that mimic where you actually spend your time. A compact EDC multitool also belongs in a field-ready setup.

Bottom line: Gear is only half the battle; your ability to retain your weapon and use it effectively under stress is what truly determines your safety.

Maintaining Your Equipment

An open-carry setup is exposed to more dust, moisture, and debris than a concealed one. Make it a habit to inspect your holster and firearm at the end of every trip. Check for loose screws on your holster's belt loops or retention clips. Wipe down your sidearm with a light coat of oil to prevent rust, especially if you’ve been sweating or caught in the rain. For weather-ready carry companions, our Camping collection is a helpful place to browse.

Check the "tension" of your holster regularly. Over time, the screws that provide friction or hold the retention hoods in place can vibrate loose. A quick check with a screwdriver once a month can prevent a catastrophic gear failure in the field. At BattlBox, we always recommend carrying a small multitool in your EDC kit for these exact types of field repairs, and our EDC collection has plenty of options.

Conclusion

Deciding whether you should open carry comes down to a clear-headed assessment of your needs and your environment. For the dedicated woodsman or the hiker traversing predator-heavy terrain, the accessibility and comfort of open carry are hard to beat. However, the added responsibility of weapon retention and the potential for social friction in urban areas cannot be ignored. Whether you choose to carry openly or concealed, the most important factors are the quality of your gear, your knowledge of the law, and your commitment to regular training. If you want a deeper look at membership and what comes with it, Getting the Most out of Your BattlBox Subscription is worth a read.

• Always prioritize a high-retention holster for open carry.
• Use a dedicated gun belt to ensure stability.
• Remain situationally aware to mitigate retention risks.
• Check local laws before crossing state or municipal lines.

Key Takeaway: Proper open carry requires a specialized holster, a rigid belt, and a high level of situational awareness to be both safe and effective.

At BattlBox, our mission is to provide the gear and knowledge you need to be prepared for any adventure. From high-retention holsters and tactical belts to the training tools that help you sharpen your skills, we are here to support your journey toward self-reliance. If you're looking to build your kit with gear that's been vetted by professionals, subscribe to get expert-curated gear delivered to your door every month

FAQ

Is open carry better than concealed carry for hiking?

For many hikers, open carry is superior because it allows for a more comfortable draw while wearing a backpack with a hip belt. It also provides faster access to your firearm in the event of a sudden animal encounter, such as a bear or mountain lion. However, it does require you to be more diligent about keeping your firearm clean and protected from the elements. If you’re planning a backpacking trip, What Gear Do You Need for Backpacking? is a good next step.

Do I need a special holster for open carry?

Yes, you should never open carry in a simple friction-only holster. A Level 2 or Level 3 retention holster is highly recommended to prevent the firearm from falling out during physical activity or being taken by someone else. These holsters feature mechanical locks that must be intentionally deactivated by the wearer during the draw. If you want a deeper look at fit and comfort, How to Choose a Concealed Carry Holster: A Comprehensive Guide is a useful companion read.

Can I open carry in all 50 states?

No, open carry laws vary significantly from state to state. Some states allow "constitutional" open carry with no permit, others require a handgun license, and several states strictly prohibit the practice in most public places. You must research the specific laws of each state and locality before carrying a firearm openly.

Does open carry make me a target?

There is a tactical debate on this, but many experts believe that carrying openly can make you a "priority target" for a criminal who wants to neutralize any potential resistance. While it may deter some, it removes the advantage of surprise that concealed carry provides. This makes high levels of situational awareness even more critical when carrying openly, and The Survival 13 is a useful framework for that mindset.